Irony of Lincoln Project’s Critique on Habeas Corpus Suspension

The Lincoln Project faced backlash after criticizing the consideration of suspending habeas corpus, a move historically enacted by Abraham Lincoln during the Civil War.

Brandon Herrera highlighted the irony, noting Lincoln’s own suspension under the 1863 Habeas Corpus Suspension Act amid rebellion.

The critique, echoed by a “King of the Hill” meme, suggests The Lincoln Project’s oversight of this history undermines their stance. Lincoln’s actions, documented in historical records, authorized such measures during national crises, directly contrasting with the group’s current opposition.

This irony reveals a potential inconsistency in their argument, given their namesake’s precedent.

The discussion underscores the complex legacy of Lincoln’s presidency and the ongoing debate over executive powers in times of emergency.

You understand you named your shitty fucking group after the other guy who did that, right?

— Brandon Herrera (@TheAKGuy) May 10, 2025

That intern is getting the belt. pic.twitter.com/KSXZILuyQP

— Nick Mac (@thecospaiacat) May 10, 2025